Loading... Please wait...

Who is Labour's backbench stalking horse? UPDATE: It's categorically not Cruddas UPDATE: Chief Whip names names

By Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

UPDATE: Labour's Chief Whip and close Brown aide Nick Brown has tonight told reporters that those behind the email include Stephen Byers, Alan Milburn, Graham Allen, Graham Stringer, Paul Farrelly.

For his own part, Farrelly has told journalists he has nothing to do with the letter and that he is "absolutely furious" at the Nick Brown's deliberate "smoking out" of backbench dissent.

Having called on members of the cabinet to challenge the PM last summer, Stringer's involvement is not out of the question, but he would also be an easy scapegoat.

UPDATE: It's not Cruddas:

A source close to Jon Cruddas has categorically told me that any suggestion that Mr Cruddas is or has been involved in the circulation of the letter calling on Gordon Brown to resign is "complete and utter rubbish". The source said Mr Cruddas has been "wholly focused" on campaigning and fighting the BNP in his Dagenham constituency, where he has been on the doorstep all day and for much of the last week.

Meanwhile, PoliticsHome has an excerpt of the letter, which reputedly says:

"We are writing now because we believe that in the current political circumstances you can best serve the interests of the Labour Party by stepping down as Prime Minister."

The snippet was obtained through the BBC's Nick Robinson.

Speculation is now spreading that Graham Allen, Labour MP for Nottingham North, may be involved in the letter's circulation.

--

With a letter reportedly doing the rounds of backbench Labour MPs, no one has yet been able to confirm who the leader of the rebels is.

Charles Clarke has a history of this sort of activity, but the Guardian reported that many Labour MPs are not signing the letter because it is being circulated by a renowned trouble-maker and championed by those that are "too left wing".

That leaves two viable liklihoods:

Frank Field and Jon Cruddas.

Qui bono?

Posted on Jun 03, 2009 at 02:53pm

49 Comments · Show / Hide
Leave a comment »   show trash comments ·
"him and his wife on £100k+ a year..."

More like £200k+. Ms Cooper alone is on £141k, whereas Eddie is just bringing in pin-money on £95k...plus all the allowances that they need!!
Lord Elpus @ 35 weeks and 4 days ago
If anyone knows who these plotters are then they should be named. Also, if they don't have the intestinal fortitude to come into the light, then they should crawl back into the darkness from whence they came.
jim paton @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
If Iwere Cameron, I'd seriously think "sorry mate not wanted". Vile man.
bbJ - Posting like Mr Kipling... exceedingly good stuff. @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Governing party tearing itself apart, bloody great. It's embarrassing, especially on the door step
Bearded Socialist @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
I have wondered whether Purnell may turn to the dark side. The only reason I think he is Labour is because Tony Blair was the first MP to respond to his requests for work experience for the summer holidays of his PPE degree!
King Kong @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
It would seem that the party has two sections. When the dust has settled a new party shall rise from the ashes. Change is a good thing and you should not be frightened.
jackie sparrow @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
"The secret of success is constancy to purpose".

Good, because thats exactley what the Tories want, keep Brown in to continue screwing it up. If you continue apologising for him then their is a chance. Vote Brown for leader.
bbJ - Posting like Mr Kipling... exceedingly good stuff. @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
It was Benjamin Disraeli who said: "The secret of success is constancy to purpose".

Sort the economy, commit to electoral reform, and act speedily on the expenses debacle.

Julian Ware-Lane @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
"The goal for Labour supporters should be how best to survive this crack-up and do as well as possible in the general election."

Sadly, I disagree. The goal for Labour supporters must be to ensure that there is at least one party which fights for equality and social justice - at the moment, there are none. A crushing electoral defeat for nuLab might just mean that under new leadership there was some slight prospect of having a Labour party in fact, not just in name.
Nick Weeks @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Balls isn't a millionaire. Really? I'd be very surprised if he isn't. Two houses, the one in London worth 600k+; him and his wife on £100k+ a year...
Hugh Pettit @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
The only force that Brown is using is Zen and the economy is shagged.
bbJ - Posting like Mr Kipling... exceedingly good stuff. @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Guest posts required from any minority party in tomorrows election on the Old Holborn Blog

I will not censor any article.

100,000 visitors await your article
Old Holborn @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Looks like curtains for New Labour. You must remember what it was like in 1917, I mean 1997. All the excitement and optimism. Thiiiings can only get better. End of sleaze and no more of the nasty party.

Look where we are 12 yrs later. Economy in tatters and politics in disgrace. When will you socialists ever learn?
Phil Mill @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Tom. In a way I agree, but we have to be practical. I suspect labour will lose the next election, and in all probability the one after. It might be a good idea to get a ueber-Blairite in now, because whomever becomes next labour leader is unlikely ever to become P.M. Perhaps the Blairites, who seem none to bright, and who still think their hero could have won them the fourth term, need to have one final lesson. I would suggest Purnell becomes leader and he will join the ranks of Duncan-Smith, Hague and Michael Howard - men who led and then got discarded.

I suspect the next Labour P.M. is somebody we don't even know of yet. Somebody who won't be contaminated by the stink of Blair. That lets out most of the current shower. The next labour leader, I think should be Jon Cruddas because he would drag the party back to slightly left of centre. We don't need any more right wing ranters
Alan Giles @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
The last thing the party needs is another "New Labour" walking disaster area.

It has to be someone not tainted by Phony Tony or bumbling Brown.

Tom Sacold @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Actually James you sum it up well. Field is much more a Tory than a Labour man. it's just that being MP for Birkenhead you HAVE to wear a red rosette. I think that is where Purnell got his hoity-toity act from. Mind you if Labour did lose the general election badly, I think they would do a Shaun Woodwrd and Quentin davies in reverse, and come out of the closet (politically of couyrse, before i get censored again!)
Alan Giles @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
I see a great future for him, Steven. Danny la Rue sadly passed on the other day..... Anyone know the words to On Mother Kelly's Doorstep? :)
Alan Giles @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
I think both Jon Cruddas and especially John McDonnell are of great integrity. My guess would be a wayward Blairite. Perhaps even the posion dwarf making one last piece of mischief before she goes back to Salford to prepare for defeat.
Alan Giles @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Has anyone seen this?

http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/standard/article-23703048-details/Another+blow+for+Brown+as+MPs+line+up+to+ditch+him/article.do


It seems Bumptious Barry Sheerman insists on having his two pennorth.....
Alan Giles @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
I'm more interested in which members of the cabinet knew about the guardian editorial.

This is so unedifying for the party - let's just get it over with. Either GB goes or we're out of power for a generation (again). AJ as PM could limit the tory majority to under 50 IMHO - this is what labour mps' minds should be concentrating on. The labour party is too important to be sacrificed on the altar of one politician's ego.
A H @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Actually how about little Hazel as a stalking Chihuahua?


Seriously why didn't Brown have the sense to do what I suggested weeks ago and sack her immediately?. As it is, the grinning 4ft 10 of nothing has, literally, the last laugh.

She has always been an ultra-Blairite, and admaned pestential nuisance.

If he had sacked her and Smith (and McNulty) the Smith/Blears duo couldn't have acted in concert like they did, just a day before local elections.


I have sympathy for Blears in only one thing: that is, it was wrong brown singled her out when both hoon and purnell had done exactly what she did - avoid CGT. To their slight credit Hoon and Blears did pay back some of the money. Tightwad Purnell, I think is hanging on to every penny.
Alan Giles @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Yes it was disgusting that Boris Johnson could be so paltry as to try to get £16 for a poppy wreath. And unlike Balls he is a millionaire.

It's been a gloomy day - but Frank Field as a prospective leader?

The mind boggles -laugh? I thought I'd ****** myself!
Alan Giles @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
Charles Clarke?

Now as a person who has never ever voted for Labour, Charles Clarke is a man who appears to be in the possession of '2 certain spherical items', unlike the current leader of the government and Charles Clarke is someone who I would actually vote for.

Even Margaret Thatcher managed to have those two items, why is the current male prime minister so sadly lacking in them?
Mark Russell @ 35 weeks and 5 days ago
I'm really struggling to understand what problem people can possibly have with a political blog that reports on political speculation and rumours, particularly a rumour held solid enough to be reported all over the mainstream media. Are labour-minded people not interested in who's likely to be PM next week? Are you determined that this site should be crashingly dull?
Certainly if it were a Tory government falling to pieces, the right wing blogs would be full of these types of stories, and you might notice that they're fairly successful.
Hugh Pettit @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
This is a good day for the Telegraph to have hidden Boris's £16 claim for a wreath. And, incredibly, that Douglas Carswell - the Tory MP who most campaigned against the speaker, was as house flipper and claimed things just as embarrassing and trivial as anybody else - see http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1190470/Ex-education-secretary-Estelle-Morris-claimed-thousands-refurbish-flat-months-stepping-down.html
Paul Halsall @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
I agree with Chris Paul this sort of activity the day before an election, without any apparent concern for it's effect on Labour voters, is problematic. The goal for Labour supporters should be how best to survive this crack-up and do as well as possible in the general election.
Paul Halsall @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
I don't think this situation is the same as Thatcher/Heseltine. If Harriet Harman were to come forward and say she will stand against GB for the sake of the party I think she would be supported. Everyone else would then come out of the woodwork and she may not win but I don't believe standing will instantly discredit her or anyone else for that matter.

If one of the "usual suspects" sticks their neck out it will be easier for GB to survive. If a member of the cabinet were to step forward and be absolutely scathing towards Brown there wouldn't be a leadership election there would be a general election and this whole sorry mess would come to an end.

This situation is a perfect example of what the public hate about our politics. The government is in disarray but the outcome is still up to party insiders and hangers on. We need a general election to return the power to the people and take it away from those who've been so thoroughly discredited.
Thomas Snoxell @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
Interesting that you believe that Labour have problems with management. Government is all about the management of the economy; management of the education system; management of the police and justice; management of the prisons; management of the armed services et al.

No wonder the country is in such a mess with clearly incompetent management running it.
Sungei Patani @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
This "left" and "right" ding dong is like watching engineering and marketing tear each other apart. Somwhere in there people might like to focus on shipping a product and customer service. Politicians (and Labour politicians) are nothing special whatever their *sigh* ideology or status *rolls eyes* as MPs. Nobody is "entitled" to win but nor is crashing and burning inevitable. People are looking like prize tools at the moment and need to focus on getting over themselves.
Charles Hardwidge @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
I hold out a vague hope that he'll cross the floor and be given the 'unthinkable' welfare reform role.
Mike Thomas @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
i thought he was considered a front runner for speaker
david cheeseman @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
Did I miss something? When did the "too left wing" start supporting anything Frank Field did?
Spartak St Albans @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
That's "cui bono". So much for education, education, education.
Andrew Kinsman @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
"Too left wing" could be a rumour put out by Downing St to discredit the group.
Theo Grzegorczyk @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
Jesus Chris, my eyes, my eyes!

Who did your blog layout? Stevie Wonder?

In case you are a Hardwidger and eschew the MSM - It's all over the Telegraph, Times, Guardian, Independent, Sun, Daily Mail, Daily Express...

There still cheeky Kev though keeping the Brown end up in the Mirror though so all's not lost.
Mike Thomas @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
I don't hate him I pity him. Going through life looking like a washed out over the hill Kenneth Williams impersonator can't have been easy. No wonder he's got a chip or ten on his shoulder.
Steven Jago @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
The force isn't with them... although the Police Force may be with some of them in the not too distant future!
Steven Jago @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
hear hear
John Powell @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
Pity, Bono is about the only person who could get Labour reelected at the moment...
Robert Michaels @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
There's an election tomorrow. Could we have less of this self-fragging until at least that's done with? There is so much confused speculation here. Apparently there is no physical letter, just some emails, so how are "the usual suspects" getting blamed? In the past it's been the ones who are "too right wing" who've been most "at it" in such activity with the McDonnelite's waiting for a vacancy. So less of the smears comrades.

Meacher is more likely by far if this is from the left. Or perhaps Kilfoyle or BMA, who wanted a punt at Blair a couple of years back. However the new right are far more into this self-destructive bollocks than the rump of the left.
Chris Paul @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
Peter Hain
Ricardo's Ghost @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
I don't think Bono will leave U2 for MP's pay.
The Very Celia Stobart @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
One of the big problems with parliament is politicians are so obsessed with power and populism they can forget to be professional. Labour have a problem with management just as much as the Tories are nasty, and the Liberals have no spine. If they spent less time investing in their egos they'd generate better outcomes.

I watched some coverage of the Last Labour conference. It was a much more well produced affair than they're used to but the usual suspects started whining about control freakery, pimping their hairshirts on the fringe, or running off with their mouths in elevators. It's like they're scared of change and have a death cult problem.

I've lost the link to it but there was a good article on how Star Wars made it from concept to the screen. While George Lucas vision was a bit hazy he had good team leaders and staff who helped bring their skills and enthusiasm to the project to make it succeed way, way better than was originally conceived. Labour need to learn this.
Charles Hardwidge @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
Frank Field is well liked by my lot, I guess that must mean you Socialists hate him?
James - Man of the Right @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
My guess is either John McDonnell or Michael Meacher.
Mike Thomas @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
Except he'll have a front operation to hide behind...
Tom Miller @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
'Renowned trouble maker Jon Cruddas'

Alex, what a slur! As if Cruddas would be getting his hands dirty in this! No doubt people are circulating it, but Cruddas, as if! Try McDonell or the MP for Neath!

In any case, a petition is a waste of time - the backbenchers would look far more credible walking down Downing St and telling Brown to go to his face.
Dave Lewis @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
Has to be Alan Johnson...
Tom Miller @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago
It's "cui" bono, isn't it?
Chris Chris @ 35 weeks and 6 days ago