Loading... Please wait...

Shattering Flint letter to Brown says the women in his cabinet are "little more than female window dressing"

Caroline FlintFrom @LabourList

Below is the cutting resignation letter from Caroline Flint to Gordon Brown, which accuses the Prime Minister of sexism:

Dear Gordon

I believe the achievements of the Labour Government to date have been monumental and you have played an immense part in the creation of those achievements.

However, I am extremely disappointed at your failure to have an inclusive Government.

You have a two tier Government. Your inner circle and then the remainder of Cabinet.

I have the greatest respect for the women who have served as full members of Cabinet and for those who attend as and when required. However, few are allowed into your inner circle. Several of the women attending Cabinet – myself included – have been treated by you as little more than female window dressing. I am not willing to attend Cabinet in a peripheral capacity any longer.

In my current role, you advised that I would attend Cabinet when Europe was on the agenda. I have only been invited once since October and not to a single political Cabinet - not even the one held a few weeks before the European elections.

Having worked hard during this campaign, I would not have been party to any plan to undermine you or the Labour Party in the run up to 4 June. So I was extremely angry and disappointed to see newspapers briefed with invented stories of my involvement in a “Pugin Room plot.”

Time and time again I have stepped before the cameras to sincerely defend your reputation in the interests of the Labour Party and the Government as a whole. I am a natural party loyalist. Yet you have strained every sinew of that loyalty.

It has been apparent for some time that you do not see me playing a more influential role in the Government. Therefore, I have respectfully declined your offer to continue in the Government as Minister for attending Cabinet.

I served six years as a backbencher and, therefore, I am not unhappy to be able to devote myself to promoting my constituency’s interests and to support the Labour Government from the backbenches.

This is a personal decision, which I have not discussed with colleagues.

Yours

Caroline

Posted on Jun 05, 2009 at 05:42pm


52 Comments · Show / Hide
Leave a comment »   show trash comments ·
remind me, is this a progressive party?
Thomas Snoxell @ 64 weeks and 3 days ago

Totty in action

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Tty39v14IM

Crazy Carrot @ 64 weeks and 4 days ago


Says it all really.....


http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/05/15/article-0-04F54C5A000005DC-252_634x379_popup.jpg
Crazy Carrot @ 64 weeks and 4 days ago
Caroline Flint has behaved like a spoilt child, having a tantrum when she doesn't get what she wants. Do her, Blears and Purnell really think that they speak for ordinary members of the party? Martin Lewis is right, they should all sink without trace.
tories aretrolls @ 64 weeks and 4 days ago
Well she did throw her toys out of the pram didnt she, immature i would call it,if she did that in any other organisation she would be sacked,as for that silly Purnell bloke he let the side down , he doesnt dserve to get another hance..
martin lewis @ 64 weeks and 4 days ago
The fact that we still have undemocratic all women shortlists completely rubbishes any accusations of sexism directed against women by the Labour leadership.
King Kong @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
Caroline Flint was really a ghastly version of Virginia Bottomley posing as a "Labour" figure - the hard, arrogance for example of, in January 2008 propounding the idea that people who were unemployed for any length of time should not be allowed to apply for social housing. She is no more "Labour" than Purnell or Norman Tebbit.

I think now she has had her public tantrum she will very soon be forgotten. Hopefully like that other member of the "Division Belles" (I'm not joking) Hazel Blears they will lose their seats at the next election and they can devote more time to tap-dancing, which is just about all they are fit for. Perhaps Purnell and Hutton could join them for a soft-shoe shuffle.
Alan Giles @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
The standard line of an spologist. "Tell you what if we dont like them we'll call them Tories" Suggest you find a video of Flint on Question time and then think about your comment. She's a total leftie.

SAD SAD comment.
bbJ - Posting like Mr Kipling... exceedingly good stuff. @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
If Caroline Flint was trying to make a point in the press today posing like a piece of eye candy then she has failed! Her resignation makes little sense in view of her newspaper appearances today and for me it has show the self centred side to her. I would have thought that it would have been a little more wise if she had looked at whether she was actually fit for higher office.
Stephen Mogridge @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
"I believe the achievements of the Labour Government to date have been monumental and you have played an immense part in the creation of those achievements."
So that would be illegal wars, lying to parliament to get them to support illegal wars. Dismantling our education system. Removing any elements of personal liberties. Spying on the population of the country. Appeasing fundamentalists and failing to defend free speech. I could go on.
Monumental indeed the most reactionary government since the Reform act. And now the final insult, the actual membership of the government contains more unelected people than at any time since the reform act.
Goodbye and good riddance to Caroline Flint and all the other self centred tossers. Lets hope Mandy and Gordie won't be far behind.
Pete Marshall @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
She is pictured in todays papers, pouting, in a red dress showing plenty of celeveage and lipstick. It puts you in mind of the publicity photos for the 1947 Rita Hayworth film "Gilda" (THERE'S a bit of cinema history for you!).

If she doesn't want to be treated as totty she shouldn't act the role so convincingly.
Alan Giles @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
Interesting that Flint gets her bra in a twist about 'feminine window dressing' just as we all get to see the pics from her Observer photo-shoot where she appears to be, er, showing off quite a lot of feminine window dressing. Interesting piece of doublethink.

Anyway, Dale mused on Sky last night whether or not Brown was demonstrating the symptoms of a breakdown during another execrable press conference. I think the answer to that is yes. Gordon Brown, lying through his teeth, grinning like a loon and in total denial, has clearly descended into paranoid delusion. At least Caligula was actually able to make his horse a Consul ...
Jules Wright @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
Stolen from Nick Robinson's Blog:

"I think this is a full list of the unelected members of HM Government, literally "lording" it over us. Others please feel free to add to it."

Lord Mandelson
Lord Sugar
Lady Kinnock
Lord Myners
Baroness Vadera
Lord Davies
Lord Carter
Lord Adonis
Baroness Andrews
Lord Bach
Lord Darzi
Lord Davidson
Lord Hunt
Lord McKenzie
Lord Malloch-Brown
Baroness Morgan
Baroness Royall
Baroness Scotland
Baroness Taylor
Lord West
Lord Young
-----

Conclusion:
The PLP seemingly doesn't have enough talent to provide the necessary people - and obviously not enough backbone to demand that a Labour government should comprise chiefly of elected members.
Max Sceptic @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
It's a bit rich of Ms Flint to complain of being used as female window dressing when she plays up to that image to the hilt. Barely a month ago, she posed for a series of glamour puss piccies and is not above playing the glamour puss card when it is in her interests.
patrick powell @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
Sorry, but what kind of credibility has Flint got? Reminds of Clare Short on the gulf war....but in reverse.

She protests her undying loyalty then flounces off 24 hours later when she doesn't get a plum job. Motives clearly venal. And - what a surprise, she then plays the sexist card.

Its probably true Brown doesn't like women very much so there is a kind of poetic justice in all these misandrist Labour wimmin getting their comeuppance from a misogynist.
Andrew Cadman @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
Live by the skulduggery, the back stabbing the spin
Die by ... well what do you expect?
Tess Hauke @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
A classic example of why I am fed up with the PM
Paul Burgin @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
I'm unemployed and seeing as you don't need to be elected to be in the government anymore, I could do that. Go on, gissa job.
Charlie Farley @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
I notice Alan Sugar signed a contract to supply HM Govt with new PC's a month ago.

Old Holborn @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago


Well wouldn,t you want a big bung to go and work for Mr Disaster

June 2007
Brown "I think we're moving from a period when celebrity matters

Ha


Crazy Carrot @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
'Government IT Project'.

A term synonymous with overpriced, badly specified, corruptly procured, over schedule, disaster.
Max Sceptic @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
He probably just off-loaded a warehouse full of Amstrads.
MonkeyBot 5000 @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
The problem with Sugar is that his great days are well in the past now: Back in the mid 80s he took over and streamlined and improved the Sinclair range, he introduced the PcW a computer in all but name that did away with the typewriter, but after that.....he bought the "E Mailer" phone to market about 5 years too late, at a time when all ISPs offered free email, and now... main occupation "property developer" which covers a multitude of architectural sins, and a cod TV "personality" on a cheap and tacky reality TV show. Alas, Sir Alan, I knew him, Horatio......
Alan Giles @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
Hard to believe, but it was only two days ago that Hazel Blears resigned.

What do you think will happen by Monday?
Max Sceptic @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago



Listening to Harriet on tonight’s C4 News defend the fact that there are now only 4 females in the cabinet was a sheer and unadulterated delight.

oooooooooo the inner turmoil

Crazy Carrot @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Let's be honest Smith,Blears,Flint & Beckett were crap,simply not fit for purpose.
roger alexander @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Not to mention Purnell and McNulty.

This week it has been a large boil has been lanced off Labour's backside, and all the pus has drained away...
Alan Giles @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
Yep! Say it like it is and keep it real!
Jim Davidson @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
Caroline Flint's resignation and accompanying letter provide yet another damning indictment of Gordon Brown's complete lack of personal authority. No one supports him apart from those who directly stand to benefit from his continued Premiership. Labour MPs shamefully cling to office knowing that an extra year's pay and pension will be in their own personal interest. Power-hungry Ministers grasp at preferment with no regard for the party or the electorate.

Another way of putting this, beyond Gordon Brown's raw power he has zero influence on people. No one buys into his charisma, wisdom or ideals. He has power but not leadership, position but not authority. He is a lame duck and the kindest thing would be to put him out of his misery.

Anyone in the Labour party with a shred of integrity would agree that for the good of the country this failed non-entity has to resign with immediate effect.
Phil Mill @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Phil: "Caroline Flint's resignation and accompanying letter provide yet another damning indictment" .......... of the arrogance of lightweight, Blairite "thinkers" who are in politics only for what they can personally get out of it.

Apparently Flint thought that by backing Brown she would be offered a cabinet job, when she wasn't she had a tantrum - hence the resignation and her ungracious resignation letter (though slightly less impolite than that of Blears - the one they call "Wa Gob"!
Alan Giles @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
He should have sacked her... a long time ago!
Jim Davidson @ 64 weeks and 5 days ago
How do Labour MPs feel about the fact that Brown holds them in contempt.

Why else would he appoint unelected placemen/women like the shop-soiled G. Kinnock?
Max Sceptic @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Another one bites the dust.

No real loss. How she ever graduated from being a part-time cashier at Morrison's to becoming an MP in the first place remains a mystery.

(Funny, I've not noticed any comments along the lines of "Hell hath no fury.... ")
Max Sceptic @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago

Oh Max come on… nothing wrong with decorating the room with a bit of “till girl tottie”

How else would you neutralise the dementors.


Crazy Carrot @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
True, true.

Having seen last week's QT, I assume that once Flint opened her mouth the dementors would run screaming for the exits...
Max Sceptic @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago


Well Tottie isn’t supposed to exceed its design envelope and actually speak, let alone on air.

Who let her do that I wonder?




Crazy Carrot @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Brown actually got something right !!

He refused to promote Flint any further beyond here abilities than he already had !!

Shame about the rest of his cabinet, but there you go.
tory 'killed for telling the uncomfortable truth' troll @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
You're too kind - what abilities?. She was another little lightweight, like her pal, the poison dwarf and THEIR friend Purnell. Mind you, you shouldn't be too hard on her, TT and Max - she is really one of yours - a Tory in all but name
Alan Giles @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
this all smacks of tribal football supporters claiming the recently sold star striker was always
rubbish, or failing rock groups (second
on the bill to puppets) claiming the departed
guitarist was a waste of space before launching into Jazz Odyssey.

Look at the high class new blood replacing Flint and purnell (not themselves the sharpest tools in the box).
la kinnock. s'ralan. bob ainsworth, for god's sake. it's the sound of the barrel being scraped.

and Flint's accusations about a two tier cabinet and about women
as decoration are bang on the money.
Tokyo Nambu @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Oh dear Tokyo, you're not on about football again are you :)

Women as window dressing, I think Baroness Vadera would disagree but she's not allowed near a tv camera ever since the 'green shoots' episode.

As for the two tier cabinet? Plus ca change, plus c'est la meme chose.

Tony Blair didn't exactly consult widely did he? If you could fit them on a sofa, that was enough.

And as for the opposition?

In other respects, however, Project Cameron is built around far too tight a circle. Frontbenchers complain that they are not involved in their development of their policy briefs. Very few of the party's big economic brains have been actively consulted by the leadership on the current challenges. The shadow cabinet rarely takes important decisions.

Taken from ConservativeHome (27/10/2008)

Simon Leonard @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Thank Alan, but

a) I'm not a Tory.

b) she's definitely not my type. I have standards.
Max Sceptic @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
She is so attractive when she's angry.

Brown is finished, and to the apologists, all the words in support of Brown - perhaps you want to reflect on what you said and why you said it.
bbJ - Posting like Mr Kipling... exceedingly good stuff. @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
My God, Flint is in a strop about her beloved tap-dancing pal Blears. In 24 hours she has changed from being a "loyal" member of the Brown clan to this histrionic and petulant "resignation" statement.

She has always played on her looks. here is the woman who suggested people who were unemployed should not be considered for social housing. The woman who admitted, while Eue te Minister that she hadn't bothered to read the treaty documents. Another closet Tory flounces out: perhaps like Hutton and Purnell she should cross the floor where their ultra Right wing views would be better appreciated,
Alan Giles @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
That's a fair comment. Flint isn't popular due to her welfare attitudes, and her "playing on her looks" may have given her a complex. Her thinking that women were just perceived as "window dressing" may just have been her paranoia.

Looking at those leaving the cabinet, some wanted to retire from cabinet, others were unfortunately tainted by circumstance or mistakes, and some like Flint had the whiff of dead man walking. I've got no objections to this flushing exercise.
Charles Hardwidge @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
hyp⋅o⋅crite

  /ˈhɪpəkrɪt/ Show Spelled Pronunciation [hip-uh-krit] Show IPA
–noun

1. a person who pretends to have virtues, moral or religious beliefs, principles, etc., that he or she does not actually possess, esp. a person whose actions belie stated beliefs.

2. a person who feigns some desirable or publicly approved attitude, esp. one whose private life, opinions, or statements belie his or her public statements.
Peter Milner @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Peter - if there's swearing in a comment it gets put in the trash can, which people can still see by clicking the "show trash" option at the top of the comments bar. They're not getting deleted.
Alex Smith @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Ok so it was a bit trashy but so is Caroline Flint.
Peter Milner @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
So is the Salford pigmy.
roger alexander @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Good one!
Max Sceptic @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
Oi I like Flinty. I hate her politics though.
bbJ - Posting like Mr Kipling... exceedingly good stuff. @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
She's lovely. Like the Nigella of politics. Not Nigel Lawson though.
Zinedine Kilbane @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago
But Nigella's got class.
roger alexander @ 64 weeks and 6 days ago