Loading... Please wait...

Is this picture of Shaun Bailey photoshopped?

From LabourListShaun Bailey

This image, from Hammersmith Tory candidate Shaun Bailey, shows him shaking hands with council leader Stephen Greenhalgh - the new poster boy for hard-right, service-cutting Tories in local government - with other local Tory councillors. He is, according to the leaflet, "congratulating Tory councillors" on cutting council tax.

But look more closely - doesn't Shaun Bailey look unusually tall? He looks to be over a foot taller than Cllr Greenhalgh, but in the image below it appears that they're roughly the same height.

Unless Shaun Bailey has mysteriously grown to be about 7 feet tall, it looks like something odd's going on.

Look again at Greenhalgh and Bailey's hands in their handshake in the top photo. On closer inspection, it looks like Cllr Greenhalgh's hand oddly changes colour where it meets Mr Bailey's.

Would a better photoshopper have used the blur tool more effectively?

We already know that the Tories have previous when it comes to amending History to suit their own agenda, so if someone amongst Hammersmith's Conservatives could just confirm that this photo is genuine we'd appreciate it.

Or did their parliamentary candidate get photoshopped into an event he couldn't be bothered to attend?

Posted on Mar 18, 2009 at 12:54pm

30 Comments · Show / Hide
Leave a comment »   show trash comments ·
A lot say LabourList is little more than student politics. Some say it is not.

I hope this post clears things up.
Carlos H @ 51 weeks ago
Is there any evidence to suggest that?
Tom Miller @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
That is truly brilliant, lol
Tom Miller @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Another Photoshop job from Mr Bailey
http://www.shaunbailey.co.uk/media/lightbox_images/housing.jpg

Jacob @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
I dunno Celia. I think the guy in front of him was part of the original photo with Bailey. So two people have been photoshopped in...
Jacob @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Purnell posed for two photos so he could be Photoshopped-in. He then lied to try to cover it up.

Ridiculous, vain, preening little man that he is.
The Very Celia Stobart @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Purnell (twice).
The Very Celia Stobart @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Check out the warm back-lighting and the hair of the guy in front of him - it's either a genius Photoshop job or it's real.

Will you be posting a retraction if proven wrong?

Or will you brazen it out like PURNELL did. TWICE?
The Very Celia Stobart @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Although I'd be careful about accusing the Tories for "amending History to suit their own agenda" as Labour seem to be very quick at forgetting the past when it suits (ERM and Black Wednesday springs to mind), Mr Bailey needs his head testing if indeed he has Photoshopped the image(s).

Hey, why doesn't someone ask him??? No?? Don't worry, I've emailed him :-)
Gordon Brown-Nose @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Blimey, eveyone is talking about it constantly. Don't you ever get bored of it?

There were posts on the crunch, but the more serious ones are quite a while ago.
Tom Miller @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
What a waste of space.

Where is the real debate on the biggest economic problem in 50 years? Nowhere to be seen on Labourlist.org. :-(
Godfrey Richards @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Type in 'Shaun Bailey' on Google Images, it's on the first page.
Tim Davies @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
http://img256.imageshack.us/img256/7711/churchill.jpg
Steven Nash @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
If you look really closely you can see Norman Lamont in the background.
Steven Nash @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
So who is Shaun Bailey, why should we care about a "photoshopped" picture and why is LabourList wasting time on it when thee are so many questions to answer still (in fact all the questions asked remaim unanswered)
George Woodhouse @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
That's hilarious. In this photo David Cameron is taller than Shaun Bailey who in turn looks like he should applying to the NBA in the other photo. So that makes DC about 8 foot tall, truly a political giant :)

Louis Mazzini @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Who cares?
Obnoxio The Clown @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
lol, They just murge together at the waist.

Imagine being a cojoined twin of David Cameron.
Keir Stitt @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Actually, Tim, I'm not sure about that one. In the first picture Shawn (geddit?) Bailey's eyebrows are raised. In the second, his eyebrows are angry and mad. I think maybe Cameron's been photoshopped IN?
Alex Smith @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
yep, thats the one.
well done finding the oroginal pic of him.
this guy is a joke.
C 123 @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
You're talking about this photo presumably?

To me it looks like they've taken him from this photo: http://blog.ivanpope.com/roadblog/images/2007/05/02/bailey.jpg

An obvious photoshop if I've ever seen one.
Tim Davies @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Interesting. We've also come across another interesting story about Mr Bailey, via our Hammersmith source:

http://frankowenspaintbrush.wordpress.com/2009/03/18/shaun-bailey-manufactured-photo-manufactured-candidate/
VoteRed GoGreen @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Brilliant. Standard lazy tories with thier tesco value photoshop software.
The one of Bailey and Cameron is fantastic (http://www.shaunbailey.co.uk/pages/home/about-shaun.php)
In the run up to the election I'm looking forward to seeing Bailey shaking hands with Churchill
Jay McGregor @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
that isn't the only photoshoped picture of Shaun Bailey.
If you go to his website and to the page "about Shaun"
http://www.shaunbailey.co.uk/pages/home/about-shaun.php
there are a load of pictures on the right hand side.
the second bottom picture on the right hand column is a picture of him and cameron.
the picture looks like they have been photoshoped together in front of a threshers in fulham.
neither bailey or cameron are in the street and they certanly aren't standing next to eachother.
an even more blatant photoshop than the one you have pointed out here.
C 123 @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
Awkward pose etc. But perhaps he's standing on a soapbox or flower bed or something? The bottom right hand guy looks the most flown in. There is a bit of a "moray" pattern across the whole picture because it is a scan of a picture that has already been screened. That doesn't help the forensic examination.

He does look a little "sharper" than the others. But then he's the PPC innit, and more of a clothes horse that the muppety ones. I'd not be surprised if the main picture including Shaun is "right" even though it looks awkward.
Chris Paul @ 51 weeks and 1 day ago
The headline says it like everyone should already know who Shaun Bailey is.

Personally, I wouldn't know my Shaun Bailey from my Busharat Ali (who clearly *does* know how to use the blur tool to some effect.)

http://www.order-order.com/2007/04/why-you-should-never-photoshop-election/


james thompson @ 51 weeks and 2 days ago
Best person to ask is Purnell
crown blog @ 51 weeks and 2 days ago
Hang on, it wasn't Labour that photoshopped Purnell in!
Tom Miller @ 51 weeks and 2 days ago
James Purnell? Ring any bells? Those in glasshouses...

http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2007/sep/28/tvfakery.television
Jack Aubrey @ 51 weeks and 2 days ago
Wouldn’t you just level them and crop the handshake?

Telling porkies in politics is just stupid, but breaking the 11th commandment while you’re at it takes it to another level.

I've never understood why people bother to doctor photos, it’s pretty sad to say the least. Of all crimes it’s the easiest one to find the witnesses.
Keir Stitt @ 51 weeks and 2 days ago