Loading... Please wait...

George Osborne: wrong on the recession, wrong on recovery

OsborneBy Mark Hanson / @markhanson

The “George Osborne: Wrong on recession, Wrong on recovery” internet campaign is the latest example of Labour producing the collateral to enable their supporters to spread their message for them.

The campaign shows that George Osborne has repeatedly called it wrong; from opposing the necessary nationalisation of Northern Rock to proposing to let the recession run its course without a fiscal stimulus to boost jobs and family incomes.

The campaign looks at what the real consequences would have been if George Osborne's misjudgements had been enacted and led to a deeper, longer and more painful recession. It also helps underline the point that any signs of recovery in the economy are not down to chance, but down to the decisions taken by the Labour Government that would not have been taken had the Tories been in charge. At the same time as launching this campaign the Party will also be releasing their Labour Campaign Network – believed to be a first for any political party in the world in terms of online campaigning.

The Labour Campaign Network recognises the important work that Labour supporting bloggers and websites do to help spread the Party’s message and campaigns – and enables them to add a placeholder to their website which will always carry Labour’s very latest internet campaign.

Both the Osborne campaign creative and the Labour Campaign Network are in keeping with the core theme of Labour’s overall internet strategy – that new media is about enabling and enhancing the ability of their supporters to campaign for them.

This follows on from the success the party had just earlier this week when thousands of Ed Miliband’s online supporters co-signed a letter with him to David Cameron asking for clarification on Tory Party policy on climate changes after Ken Clarke’s remarks on wind farms – forcing Ken Clarke to retract his comments.


Posted on Oct 26, 2009 at 03:21pm


23 Comments · Show / Hide
Leave a comment »   show trash comments ·
If this is the best Labour wonks at Millbank can do, New Labour is in the deep and steaming 'big time'.

I believe that the majority of voters will recognise this for what it is; an attempt to paper over the massive cracks of New Labour's failure to deal with the real issues that need dealing with in the UK while wasting billions on a climate change argument that is so lost, the latest 'screaming minnie' climatologist is trying to save his bacon by telling us we all need to become vegetarians to save the world!

Here's a thought to deal with: many voters trust Osbourne as much as Darling - which is also about as far as we can throw both of them. This being the case, just why are the Tories on 41% of the UK vote share? Even more scary is, if you take out the fact that the Tories in Scotland are on 18% - just what level of support does that really leave the Tories in England?

So to all the 'Labour can do no wrong brigade' of activists, we'll loyally peddle what ever garbage Millbank give us, just when are you going to deal with the political reality New Labour actually finds itself in.
Peter Thomson @ 44 weeks and 2 days ago
Unfortunately, your faith in the proposition that 'anything Labour does in the recession is automatically better than the Tories would have done' is not shared by the vast amount of people in the country, who frankly just want an election to consign this Government to the pages of history.

Labour could well be fighting the next election with three million unemployed, remember that stick you used to bash the Tories with?

Labour have trashed the economy, and thus consigned many hundreds of thousands (at least) of people in this country to a life of uncertainty, impoverishment and harsh economic compromise. The very people you lot are supposed to help. Some of Brown's wizardry with pension dividend taxes will not be fully felt for decades to come, whereupon many people will be forced to forgoe retirment to keep the lights on.

The only chance we've got is to employ a Government with some concept of fiscal discipline to stop the debt becoming unmanagable.
Billy Bob @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Hi Richard

Can i ask , Do you trust the leadership of the party ? Did you belive Mr Brown when he said no-one would be hurt by the scrapping of the 10p tax? or Mr Blairs WMD ? Or the promise on the EU treaty ? Boom or bust?

ricki
ricki lake @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Hi Labourlist

If (and i mean if ) Mr Osbourne is wrong then does that mean private education is rubbish ? Would a tory goverment from 97 run up the debt ?

All we hear is wrong wrong wrong should someone investigate the private schools for levels of standerds?

ricki
ricki lake @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
I see Mark describes himself as a 'new media strategist'. Well perhaps he knows the techniques but the content is really poor.

Thousands of people signing Ed Millipede's letter is an overwhelming success he says.

What Osborne's judgements would have been if if if............

Labour 'producing the collateral'.

Oh my God!

Self important drivel with its very own collateral damage.
William Silver @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Please tell me Labour aren't really going to run this campaign.

Seriously what are you on to think that the week after the announcement that we're in the longest recession EVER RECORDED is a good time to "imagineer" what would have happened if Osborne was in charge?

And for the love of God please, unless the real intent is for this campaign to backfire even more than it will do, stop using strawmen (lies) that the Tories had no fiscal stimulus policy - they DID.

-----------
Both the Osborne campaign creative and the Labour Campaign Network are in keeping with the core theme of Labour’s overall internet strategy – that new media is about enabling and enhancing the ability of their supporters to campaign for them.
-----------

And the core theme of being totally out of touch and based on alternative realities.

The good thing about the campaign is that it's cheap - and with the Labour party on the verge of bankruptcy it needs all the cheap tricks it can get hold of.
john doe @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Mark,

You have a series of comments below, please do come back and address the points made, it is the right think to do.
john smith WB @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Errrrrr oh Richard, where do you live, here in the UK on planet Earth we ARE in the depths of depression.

http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/finance/edmundconway/100001543/this-recession-just-became-a-depression/



Crazy Carrot @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Depths? The graph clearly shows that the contraction has slowed. So unless we end up with a "double dip" (which will happen with Osborne's "do nothing" policy) the recession is coming to an end. Darling predicted that we would be out of recession by the end of the year. The signs show that we will be. (For example, house prices and sales have picked up, so there is clearly confidence in that sector.)
Richard Blogger @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Richard

Are you ignoring Darlings forecast or are you just ignorant of it?

john doe @ 44 weeks and 2 days ago
Richard, is Labours most loyal. He would eat his dinner gladly off of Labours bottom. Sadly Labour is in desperate need of a shower but this is ignored..
john smith WB @ 44 weeks and 2 days ago
Er - I a little confused now. I had thought til now that it was GB/AD who said we were coming our of recession and that we were the best placed country to do so. And yet we are now going to be last to recover, with our depression still continuing. Maybe I did get it wrong and it was Osbourne who said it. Can someone clear this up fo me please?
George Woodhouse @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Melissa Kite (Deputy Political Editor of the Telegraph and columnist on the Spectator, ie she's right wing) made an interesting comment on the Westminster Hour last night (Radio 4 Sunday, from 14:35 onwards on iPlayer). She suggested that Cameron thought that Osborne was the Tories weak point, and that Cameron was scared to put him in a debate against Darling. Personally I think she's right, Darling would make mincemeat of Osborne, especially since Osborne has no policies to speak of to help keep the country's head above the water in what is admittedly a difficult time.
Richard Blogger @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Sadly the fatal flaw in your piece is that We Labour, have seriously undermined the economy and need to address our failings before we cast stones. The public do not believe a word we say and increasing the volume of drivel out there about saving the universe changes nothing.

Excellent value add Mr Hanson.
john smith WB @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
The nationalisation of Northern Rock was wrong. In its capacity as the lender of last resort the Bank of England should have lent it the money it needed at a high rate of interest. Alternatively, Lloyds TSB should have been allowed to buy it. Either was better than nationalisation. You pose a false choice between nationalisation and doing nothing.

Turning to the bigger picture, even if you are only a "new media strategist" (whatever that means), you must have noticed the news last week that our economy remains in recession, unlike most other major Western economies. This is, no doubt, because thanks to the prudence and foresight of our beloved Prime Minister, we were best placed to deal with a global downturn (which has not produced a recession in Australia, for example) and because of the brilliant decisions he and his equally talented sidekick, Alastair Darling, made.

Twittering on about nonsense as you seem to do does not impact on the opinion polls. It does not do so because people are, in the main, not so stupid as to fall for the desperate spin and half truths which passes for Labour policy and attack lines.
Mark Cannon @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
A brilliant article . Should be reproduced in every politics textbook as a clear example of how to choose the battlefield on which to attack your opponent.

Attack them on the area where you are strongest, where your track record is largely impeccable, and where you can point to clear evidence that not only your policies are correct but they have achieved what you set out to achieve.

Oh , it;s the economy. Well that's different. By far the worst article I have read on the economy..obviously the authors don't know what they are talking about: and boy how it shows.
madasa fish @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Did Osbourne say that Britain was "best placed" to cope with the economic downturn?

If he did, I agree with you, his credibility is in absolute shreds as country after country comes out of recession whilst Britain doesn't.

Martin Dubber @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Let's be clear about this. Osborne had a do nothing policy, so whether he thought Britain was "best placed" or not is irrelevant. If Osborne had been in Number 11 last year we would be in the depths of a depression, as it is, we are coming out of recession.
Richard Blogger @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Alternatively, doing nothing would have lead to an unprecedented boom and so Labour's policy of "doing something" has prevented it.

We can both make random unfounded claims, isn't this fun.
MonkeyBot 5000 @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Huh? There is no other major economy that handled the financial crisis last year in the way that George "I haven't a clue what to do" Osborne suggested. The evidence is firmly against your claims that Cameron/Osborne's do nothing policy.
Richard Blogger @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
Err, no, we are not coming out of recession. It was confirmed on Friday that the recession continues, hence the crash in the pound's value on the same day.
Paul Pinfield @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
This article can only have been written by two stupid blind and loyal Brown followers! when your own Party contributed to the Crash with the pathetic (no ones to blame if it all goes wrong, just how Labour like it) Tri Partitie system and Browns refusal to be honest about the colossal debt hes hidden off the balance sheet how can you have a go at Osborne?

Anyone with any sense knows you cannot pay off debt with more debt! only Socialist idiots think this is the case, Browns scorched earth policy is a vain attempt to prove hes right and everyone else is wrong, just like he promised no more boom and bust! the blithering ridiculous idiot.

The UK will pay for this Economic nightmare for at least the next 20 years and the Electorate will never forget what a Socialist Goverment really is, morally and financially bankrupt.


Phillip Wells @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago
How anyone can describe a government not even willing to use the power it has in being major shareholders in banks 'socialist' is quite beyond me

All Osborne's ideas suggest is more uncritical following of the market
Mike Homfray @ 44 weeks and 3 days ago