Loading... Please wait...

Domestic Violence: it's a LGBT problem too

Domestic Violence

By Mariam Ridha

Same-sex domestic violence is real. The lastest research, ‘Count Me In Too', found that on average 1 in 3 LGBT people experience domestic abuse, an even higher incidence than amongst heterosexual women (estimated at 1 in 4). Yet the perception of domestic abuse as exclusively a ‘gendered crime' persists amongst the mainstream organizations and services offered to LGBT victims remain hugely inadequate.

Despite the government's inclusive definition of domestic violence as ‘any incident of threatening behaviour, violence or abuse (psychological, physical, sexual, financial, or emotional) between adults that have been intimate partners or family members, regardless of gender or sexuality', this has not translated to equal services for LGBT victims.

With very little recognition of same-sex abuse in mainstream domestic violence organizations, LGBT people risk not being taken seriously by precisely those who they seek assistance from, or there simply being no suitable help to offer them. Mainstream organizations continue to be oriented toward heterosexual women, with little or no understanding of LGBT issues.

Meanwhile specialist LGBT domestic violence services are scarce. With no specialist refuges, gay, bisexual, and transgender men who are attempting to escape domestic abuse from same-sex partners often have nowhere to go - while lesbian, bisexual, and transgender women in mainstream refuges face possible revictimization owing to homophobia/transphobia. LGBT specific services providing support and counselling are also extremely few on the ground despite this being the most popular request among LGBT survivors in a recent study.

This is a ‘real' problem then. Services to support LGBT victims and survivors of domestic abuse are patently unequal to those offered to mainstream sections of society, in spite of domestic violence being as prevalent a problem within the LGBT community. That is why this year LGBT Labour will campaign to move services forward for LGBT victims and achieve fairness for those who suffer in the hands of their same-sex partner.

Vitally, there is a need for training and awareness raising in all mainstream organizations related to domestic violence across the voluntary and statutory sector to improve attitudes and where possible develop expertise. Understandably not all domestic violence agencies can provide the whole package of services to LGBT people but what is necessary is that they handle victims sensitively and signpost them to the range of available services where they cannot provide these themselves. Specialist LGBT services such as safe, specialist temporary accommodation and LGBT specific support and counselling are also necessary to provide full, appropriate support.

It is not tokenistic change we are after. The discrepancy between services offered to LGBT victims of domestic abuse and mainstream sections of society leaves this group extremely vulnerable to those who perpetrate harm and needs to be addressed. Same-sex domestic violence exists and it is serious: now let's do something about it.

Posted on Apr 17, 2009 at 11:37am


11 Comments · Show / Hide
Leave a comment »   show trash comments ·
But Harriet only ever talks about protecting wimmin. So does Jacqui. We men who are victims are never considered.

When Harriet does that after she has introduced her own Equality Bill, can I sue her for breach of my rights ?
chris jones @ 71 weeks and 5 days ago
What is an LGBT - or is this artcile only mean to be read and understand by whatever LGBTs are?
George Woodhouse @ 71 weeks and 6 days ago
The 'LGBT' section of the population refers to lesbians, gay men, and the bisexual and trans men and women. And no this isn't just meant to be read by LGBT people, it is an issue of equality in our services to the vulnerable and that is an issue for all.
Mariam Ridha @ 71 weeks and 6 days ago
Lettuce, gherkin, bacon and tomato.

£3.99 at Pret a Manger.
The Very Celia Stobart @ 71 weeks and 6 days ago
Hear, hear!.

and would someone please tell our dearly beloved Home Secretary? Her woeful conflation of "violence against women","violence against children" and "domestic violence" in her introduction to the "consultation paper on violence against women and girls" (http://www.homeoffice.gov.uk/documents/cons-2009-vaw/vaw-consultation.pdf?view=Binary) is deeply insulting to those who have experienced domestic violence in a same-sex relationship, or as a child (the only one of three kids to receive such - and so unconnected to the women/girl issue)
Nick Weeks @ 71 weeks and 6 days ago
OK. So how much taxpayers' money do you want?
Max Sceptic @ 71 weeks and 6 days ago
LGBT people pay taxes too. Which go toward funding DV services. Which don't adequately protect or support them (or at all) when they are the victims of DV.

This is only a question of making mainstream services inclusive of all people who are suffering domestic violence. It's not 'liberal propaganda' to get more money from the state. LGBT victims of domestic violence simply don't get the support they need at the moment, and that's not safe, and not fair.

The DV sector is a largely voluntary sector - people do amazing work with already few resources. The fact remains however that they are massively oriented toward heterosexual women and need support if they are to move beyond this. Just training, to raise awareness, build knowledge, so on, could turn things around. This isn't about taking tax money - it's just helping organizations to accommodate the full range of DV victims, better.

Mariam Ridha @ 71 weeks and 6 days ago
If I understand you correctly, you're saying that you don't want any additional funding from the public.

Good.
Max Sceptic @ 71 weeks and 5 days ago
"Domestic Violence: it's a LGBT problem too"

No, really? How surprising to learn that being LGBT does not prevent you being violent...

How about posts that don't state the obvious?
Paul Pinfield @ 71 weeks and 6 days ago
Well..within and outside the LGBT community, for years, that fact didn't seem to be acknowledged. Only recently have people started talking about this, and recognizing that it is the same gay or straight. More to the point, there's still been no full recognition of it in the DV sector, otherwise there wouldn't be the discrepancy in services there is now. It seems obvious doesn't it.....obviously not.
Mariam Ridha @ 71 weeks and 6 days ago
"on average 1 in 3 LGBT people experience domestic abuse, an even higher incidence than amongst heterosexual women (estimated at 1 in 4)."

Could this be a related to the fact that there is a bigger social taboo around a man hitting a woman than a man hitting another man. Also, a heterosexual women reporting abuse doesn't have the added worry of dealing with prejudice over her sexuality.
MonkeyBot 5000 @ 71 weeks and 6 days ago