Loading... Please wait...

Cameron and Johnson at breaking point

Boris CameronBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

This morning's New Statesman says that Tory leader David Cameron and his Mayor of London Boris Johnson are at "breaking point, with new and potentially damaging divisions over the mayor's plans for London."

James Macintyre, who wrote for LabourList yesterday, sayss the fresh schism has arisen because of Cameron's opposition to Johnson's general election manifesto policy proposals:

* The first is Johnson's backing for Crossrail, the scheme linking Essex, Canary Wharf and Heathrow, which the government and Johnson are backing but the Statesman says Cameron will not. Crossrail is crucial to London's future as a financial capital, and is supported by City financiers and ordinary Londoners.

* The second is Johnson's plan for a new airport on an island in the Thames estuary. Tory HQ hasn't made its position clear on this, but remains opposed to a third runway at Heathrow. However, this week Conservative MP Geoffrey Clifton-Brown told a constituent in a letter that that "vote blue, get green" policy and opposition to the third runway would be revisited once the Tories were in power and the realities of office would force them to address issues more closely.

* The third cause of dispute is Johnson's wish for enhanced powers for the London Mayoralty. Cameron's opposition to this will call into doubt his commitment to devolving power away from Westminster and into local communities.

The reports throw further light on Ken Livingstone's assertion last week that Cameron was "horrified" when Johnson won the mayoralty.

Posted on Jul 23, 2009 at 09:30am


22 Comments · Show / Hide
Leave a comment »   show trash comments ·
It's not just the old Eronians at breaking point: so is the government.

A few years ago NuLabour (ToryLite) performed a great con on council house tenants. They refused to allow tenants to vote for the fourth option of keeping the homes under council control and people were only offered ALMO or Housing Association. Nonetheless dear Auntie Tony p[romised that if tenants voted for either of these options extra funds would be made available to upgrade their homes by 2010 (Prescott's Decent Homes nonsense).

Today the government announced that £150 million earmarked for several London boroughs to carry out this upgrading and decency has now been "refocused". In other words, crumbling old council homes will NOT be bought up to decent standards.

How typical of this cowering. cowardly, so-called "Labour" government that they chose to make the announcement the day AFTER Parliament rises for three months.

Nice to know NuLabour has it's priorities right, though £150 billion for the banks and two fingers for the poor.
Alan Giles @ 53 weeks and 1 day ago
Although Crossrail may be supported by most Londoners, I am less sure this is true of the rest of the country.

At the moment, Manchester to Liverpool (30 miles or so), or Manchester to Leeds (40 miles max) both take around an hour by train. Merseyside, Greater Manchester, and West Yorkshire together almost more than equal London's population (although not the whole metropolitan area), but they are massively less served by train communication.
Paul Halsall @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
In summary:

Boris is not a lap dog, and as a conservative is doing what he thinks best for London.

Cameron as conservative party leader is planning on doing what he thinks best for the country.

Sounds pretty good to me.
tory 'killed for telling the uncomfortable truth' troll @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
Alex, really

Have you run out of barrel to scrape?
Old Holborn @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
The barrel went a long time ago, burned it for intellectual fuel.
a b @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
Old Holborn and Mike, guess that confirms it then.
Ralph Baldwin @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
I don't see how point 2 amounts to a disagreement. Hasn't the Thames estuary plan, first mooted in the 70s (or late 60s?) always been intended as an alternative to an expanded Heathrow?
B Bendle @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
"James Macintyre, who wrote for LabourList yesterday, "

Yes, the man who described Gordon brown as a "towering figure".


Laugh, I thought I'd.....piece more cake, vicar? :)
Alan Giles @ 53 weeks and 1 day ago
Yep, the Maplin Sands proposal (aka Boris Island) was the Tory position regarding new airport expansion in the 1970s and into the 80s. It was a detailed proposal conducted in the early 70s. It seems the only problem was cost, however, it did offer the only solution to 24hr airport operation near London.

As a side issue, the current green paper worked on the assumption of 5% growth in air-travel since 2000, it has failed to grow by that much at all making the capacity issue far less urgent than argued.

If you follow the link 'revisited once the Tories were in power' it details a comprehensive slapping down of the unfortunate MP by the Shadow Transport Secretary and Cameron himself.

Still don't let the facts get in the way of a story.
a b @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
Oh yes, Maplin Sands - I remember now. Didn't they actually begin to build some experimental foundations?

I don't know about this story - I thought there was more evidence for a schism in the Evening Standard interview with Boris a few weeks ago.
B Bendle @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
Yeah, they did some exploratory digging to see what the sediment base was like and depth to bedrock. Of course all before recent advances in construction techniques; also there are now precedents for re-claiming land for airports.

As for a Boris v Cameron split; I cannot see how there are many journos very close to both of them for the story not to out somehow. I'm sure they will disagree on areas of policy but that's all part and parcel of the job. I think people forget how it was before being 'on message' appeared.
a b @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
Political correspondent for left-wing magazine pontificates on negative associations between two Conservatve leaders.

Nothing to see. Move along please.
Sam Francisco @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
And what do The Statesman and the illustrious Mr Macintyre have to say about today's by-election in Norwich North?
Max Sceptic @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
Max assuming this rift is real, who do you think will prevail?
Ralph Baldwin @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
Each will prevail in his own sphere: Cameron Nationally; Boris in London.

Come 2018 Boris - as a sprightly 54 year old - will, after two magnificent terms as Mayor, be ideally placed to accept the baton of Conservative PM (Cameron having resigned after his two successful stints at the helm).

Please don't all choke on your muesli!
Max Sceptic @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
I don't eat muesli,

I think Boris is being smart and clearly his position on the issue mentioned is right. I think Cameron will lose over that debate. London Mayors do seem to be a little more in touch. I am not sure any politician has a "magnificent term" I think you need to lower your expectations as you are heading towards deep disappointment, I wwould way that to anyone on politics.
Ralph Baldwin @ 53 weeks and 1 day ago
I love muesli!

They will be OK-ish... Which is still 'magnificent' in comparison to their Labour alternatives.
Max Sceptic @ 53 weeks ago
Written by the correspondent that thinks Labour can still win the next election.

It's more bunker-speak wishful thinking and the New Statesman wonders why it's losing readers.
a b @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
Quite! James Macintyre wrote some nonsense yesterday. He wrote some more today. Meanwhile, back on Planet Earth...
Mark Cannon @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
We are just getting our own back for the larging up of slight inconsistences between Labour leaders by the Tories and media over the years though it is fair to say that the Crossrail and Heathrow projects are far from slight.
David Brede @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
I thought Blair's hatred of the last Labour Mayor of London was pretty much a matter of irrefutable historical record.
Sam Francisco @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago
Seems to be a tradition of power mongering now doesn't it, Mayor vs PM.....
Ralph Baldwin @ 53 weeks and 2 days ago